• Publish Your article
  • Editorial Policy
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Advertise
Monday, December 4, 2023
  • Login
No Result
View All Result
Birmingham Times
  • Home
  • UK News
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Sports
    How Dr Martens shareholders are facing a loss of three-quarters of their investment in two years

    How Dr Martens shareholders are facing a loss of three-quarters of their investment in two years

    Owen Farrell sets unwanted record and fires back at referee on dramatic day for England captain

    Owen Farrell sets unwanted record and fires back at referee on dramatic day for England captain

    Fish and chip shop boss brands himself ‘Salt and Vinegar Bae’ after wrapping his cod in layer of 24-carat-gold

    Fish and chip shop boss brands himself ‘Salt and Vinegar Bae’ after wrapping his cod in layer of 24-carat-gold

    Danny Cipriani’s wife in furious bust-up with model ‘he chatted up’ before marriage split

    Danny Cipriani’s wife in furious bust-up with model ‘he chatted up’ before marriage split

    Senior cop involved in Stephen Lawrence murder case accused of corruption

    Senior cop involved in Stephen Lawrence murder case accused of corruption

    I’m a rugby legend who retired after the World Cup but I already have new career as manager for glass and metal company

    I’m a rugby legend who retired after the World Cup but I already have new career as manager for glass and metal company

    I’m a rich housewife with a millionaire husband, it’s not as easy as people think, I always look 10/10 and it’s tiring

    I’m a rich housewife with a millionaire husband, it’s not as easy as people think, I always look 10/10 and it’s tiring

    I’m an Oscar winner & one of most chilling Bond villains… few know my secret past as international sports star for Spain

    I’m an Oscar winner & one of most chilling Bond villains… few know my secret past as international sports star for Spain

    Israeli troops in stand-off with Iranian-backed terror groups amid fears war with Hamas will expand

    Israeli troops in stand-off with Iranian-backed terror groups amid fears war with Hamas will expand

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Fashion
    • food
    • Health
    • Travel
    Mum-of-two died after suffering brain injury from drinking too much water – as family pay tribute to ‘amazing’ woman

    Mum-of-two died after suffering brain injury from drinking too much water – as family pay tribute to ‘amazing’ woman

    People are only just realising that they’ve been peeling potatoes all wrong and their minds are blown

    People are only just realising that they’ve been peeling potatoes all wrong and their minds are blown

    Thinking of packing it in to live on the road? This is what van life is really like…

    Thinking of packing it in to live on the road? This is what van life is really like…

    More than one in five Brits admit falling asleep at work – with some dozing off on the toilet as they ‘work too hard’

    More than one in five Brits admit falling asleep at work – with some dozing off on the toilet as they ‘work too hard’

    Woman makes ‘boujee’ hamper for a tenner thanks to Aldi and proves ‘Christmas on a budget is possible for anyone’

    Woman makes ‘boujee’ hamper for a tenner thanks to Aldi and proves ‘Christmas on a budget is possible for anyone’

    This London street is among the world’s most expensive shopping destinations

    This London street is among the world’s most expensive shopping destinations

    McDonald’s launches new Happy Meal toys today – it’s perfect for kids who love Paddington

    McDonald’s launches new Happy Meal toys today – it’s perfect for kids who love Paddington

    ‘Stop telling me I look young for my age, I’m old and proud’

    ‘Stop telling me I look young for my age, I’m old and proud’

    Almost 1,000 Brits go into cardiac arrest on the operating table every year, NHS study suggests

    Almost 1,000 Brits go into cardiac arrest on the operating table every year, NHS study suggests

    M&S Food’s must-have items including the sweet treat you’ll have to buy in bulk because it’s so tasty

    M&S Food’s must-have items including the sweet treat you’ll have to buy in bulk because it’s so tasty

    Trending Tags

    • Golden Globes
    • Mr. Robot
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Climate Change
    • Flat Earth
  • Health
  • Opinion
  • Tech
  • Science
  • Travel
  • Real Estate
  • Sports
  • More
    • Crypto
    • Press Release
Birmingham Times
No Result
View All Result
Home Business

New era for transparency in family court reporting begins with pilot scheme

by Chandler
January 30, 2023
Reading Time: 8min read
0
SHARES
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Reddit


A new era of reporting from family courts in the UK begins on Monday as a pilot scheme begins.

Under the scheme, journalists may report much more freely what goes on inside family courtrooms at certain courts, including quoting family members involved.

But the easing of restrictions comes with strict requirements, including that the anonymity of families be preserved.

To help journalists navigate the new rules – and avoid being found in contempt of court – The Bureau of Investigative Journalism and freelance journalist Louise Tickle teamed up to create a website laying out the do’s and don’ts under the pilot scheme.

What’s family court reporting like now?

The current rules on reporting on family court cases were laid down in Section 12 of the Administration of Justice Act 1960, and prevent all but the most general information about a case from being published.

Tickle told Press Gazette she began going to family court cases eight years ago. “I was doing stories for The Guardian about non-molestation orders and legal aid and I knew nothing about family courts at that point, except I had a vague idea that there was that restriction on what you could report.

“And I very quickly found out that you could report almost nothing at all, which pretty much horrified me.”

In October 2018 Tickle won an effort to lift reporting restrictions on a case in which a local authority used what she called “weak evidence” to put a child into adoptive care. The victory led to new guidelines over challenging reporting restrictions in family courts, including guidance that journalists not face costs for any challenges.

Sir Andrew McFarlane, president of the Family Division of the courts, published a transparency review in October 2021 that found “there needs to be a major shift in culture and process to increase the transparency [of family courts] in a number of respects”.

At present, journalists holding a press card and authorised legal bloggers are allowed to attend most family court hearings and family proceedings at the High Court. But what information can be reported is strictly and complexly controlled.

“They can’t report anything apart from the most general gist of what happens in the courtroom,” said Tickle. “And that has been the subject of millions of pounds worth of contested case law, because nobody is confident as to what the general gist means. And it’s very, very scary if you get it wrong.”

Family members involved are also disallowed from telling journalists what happened in their court case. “They’re at risk of contempt of court for doing that – as would you be if you published what they said.”

Tickle said change had been slow in part because the rules are laid down in statute law, and there’s “a natural level of drag in Parliament” with regard to legislation not seen as urgent. But as well as that, the law’s gagging effect makes it difficult for people affected to explain their experiences.

“As media, or as people who are campaigning, it’s really difficult for them to give examples and talk about the things that are potentially going wrong, the things that they observe that need scrutiny, because you are literally not allowed to give examples of what you see in court. That is a contempt. So how do you campaign? How do you raise awareness?”

Tickle acknowledged “really strong competing arguments against greater transparency”, for example that nobody in family court cases is accused of a crime and that children’s safety and anonymity needs protecting. But she said the case for liberalisation has been growing over the past decade, in particular the last five years.

“We have the highest number of children in local authority care on record. That is a really significant public interest.”

While what goes on in family court was always important, Tickle said, “the more families affected by these powers being exerted in secret by the state, the more compelling is the reason for transparency.

“It’s taken a lot of people, from journalists like me and others, by lawyers, by judges, sometimes retired judges, arguing really from a range of different perspectives – and families themselves who’ve been through the family courts who in their view had terrible process and poor decision making – to raise the profile of this.”

What’s going to change under the scheme

The pilot scheme will take place in Cardiff, Carlisle and Leeds, and involves three main changes. The first is that the holder of a UK Press Authority press card and legal bloggers will be able to talk to family members “and assuming their case is in the scheme, will be able to quote them in their reporting,” said Tickle.

Second, journalists will be allowed access to “quite a number of documents which we always had to beg for before. And we will be allowed to quote from them.”

Lastly, journalists will be able to report what they actually see in court, which Tickle said used to be “a really serious contempt”.

Despite the easing of restrictions, families’ anonymity must still be preserved effectively. “Anonymity, for instance, in a big metropolitan area might involve less redaction of detail than [in] for instance Cumbria, which is a rural sparsely populated area,” Tickle explained.

“Effective anonymisation and imaginative, creative ways of making sure that you get editorially what you need to put in – while making sure the family are safe – will be very key…

“Even though these rules will make life a lot easier for journalists, they are still rules, and you still have to abide by them in detail.”

The new website is housed on The Bureau of Investigative Journalism site with the intention of creating “a really good place where something was detailed and gave examples and suggested how people might work to make sure that family members were as comfortable as possible,” Tickle said.

“And also to be able to work collaboratively, as far as possible, with lawyers representing the parties. Because that has been in some cases really good in my experience, but in other cases there has been a level of aggression and hostility which has made life distinctly uncomfortable for me and other journalists in family court…

“You can often get quite a long way in terms of what you’re able to report by negotiating creatively with lawyers about what will and won’t identify a family member, rather than just sort of sticking absolutely to wanting the moon on a stick.

“If you can say: ‘Well, I’ll give up the stick, I’ll just have the moon’ – then sometimes you can get there.”

Tickle suggested there were important stories about the UK that would now be easier to tell under the scheme.

“Stuff that goes on in family courts is just so compelling… it touches on so many parts of public policy and our life as a society.”

The post New era for transparency in family court reporting begins with pilot scheme appeared first on Press Gazette.



Source link

Related Posts

Google agrees $100m deal with Canadian publishers ahead of Online News Act

Google agrees $100m deal with Canadian publishers ahead of Online News Act

by Chandler
December 1, 2023
0

Google has agreed to pay CA$100m to news publishers in Canada following a long battle over payments for their content in search. Facebook and Instagram owner Meta is resisting demands that...

National World debuts AI-generated weather presenter on London site

National World debuts AI-generated weather presenter on London site

by Chandler
October 22, 2023
0

National World‘s regional website for London has debuted a totally AI-generated weather presenter. As of Friday afternoon, London World has published two daily weather bulletins under the “AI Newsroom” by-line. The...

Man of the People Bill Hagerty named Press Club Journalist Laureate

Man of the People Bill Hagerty named Press Club Journalist Laureate

by Chandler
October 18, 2023
0

At the London Press Club Ball Bill Hagerty was named Journalist Laureate for 2023. In their citation, London Press Club Ball co-chairs Robert Jobson and Ray Massey said: “Bill Hagerty truly...

Israel-Gaza war: Ten journalists killed in under a week

Israel-Gaza war: Ten journalists killed in under a week

by Chandler
October 14, 2023
0

At least ten journalists have been killed in just a week of fighting in Israel and Gaza. Nine of those killed are Palestinians either bombed or shot by the Israeli military...

‘Groundbreaking’ and ‘dreadful’: Brandreth, Myrie and Kearney among those paying tribute to LBC at 50

‘Groundbreaking’ and ‘dreadful’: Brandreth, Myrie and Kearney among those paying tribute to LBC at 50

by Chandler
October 10, 2023
0

Press Gazette joined a host of famous names from broadcast journalism to mark 50 years since the launch of LBC, the UK’s first licensed commercial radio broadcaster. LBC alumni including BBC...

To protect future newsrooms from AI fakery we must first protect the past

To protect future newsrooms from AI fakery we must first protect the past

by Chandler
October 6, 2023
0

“History is written by the victor” – and it will be rewritten by AI. Much ink has been spilled on the problem of disinformation supercharged by generative AI. The consequences of...

Next Post
Vladimir Putin threatened to kill me with a missile attack, reveals Boris Johnson in hard-hitting new BBC series

Vladimir Putin threatened to kill me with a missile attack, reveals Boris Johnson in hard-hitting new BBC series

Popular News

Google agrees $100m deal with Canadian publishers ahead of Online News Act

Google agrees $100m deal with Canadian publishers ahead of Online News Act

3 days ago
How Dr Martens shareholders are facing a loss of three-quarters of their investment in two years

How Dr Martens shareholders are facing a loss of three-quarters of their investment in two years

3 days ago
Mum-of-two died after suffering brain injury from drinking too much water – as family pay tribute to ‘amazing’ woman

Mum-of-two died after suffering brain injury from drinking too much water – as family pay tribute to ‘amazing’ woman

3 days ago
Lottery results LIVE: National Lottery Set For Life draw tonight, November 30, 2023

Lottery results LIVE: National Lottery Set For Life draw tonight, November 30, 2023

3 days ago
People are only just realising that they’ve been peeling potatoes all wrong and their minds are blown

People are only just realising that they’ve been peeling potatoes all wrong and their minds are blown

3 days ago
Huge credit to Rishi Sunak for demanding ‘real action’ from China on climate change

Huge credit to Rishi Sunak for demanding ‘real action’ from China on climate change

3 days ago
Rishi Sunak ‘takes swipe’ at Boris Johnson by declaring he ‘inherited’ high migration

Rishi Sunak ‘takes swipe’ at Boris Johnson by declaring he ‘inherited’ high migration

3 days ago
Complete fossilised skeleton of gorgosaurus to fetch up to £7m at auction

Complete fossilised skeleton of gorgosaurus to fetch up to £7m at auction

3 days ago
Birmingham Times

All Rights Reserved © Birmingham Times - The Voice of UK

Important Links

  • Publish Your article
  • Editorial Policy
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Advertise

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Politics
  • UK News
  • Business
  • Science
  • National
  • Entertainment
  • Gaming
  • Sports
  • Fashion
  • Lifestyle
  • Travel
  • Health
  • Food

All Rights Reserved © Birmingham Times - The Voice of UK

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In