• Publish Your article
  • Editorial Policy
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Advertise
Tuesday, October 3, 2023
  • Login
No Result
View All Result
Birmingham Times
  • Home
  • UK News
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Sports
    Which teams have been eliminated from the Rugby World Cup 2023?

    Which teams have been eliminated from the Rugby World Cup 2023?

    Beloved car shop finds new life after store closes down with budget supermarket set to move in

    Beloved car shop finds new life after store closes down with budget supermarket set to move in

    South Africa 8-13 Ireland LIVE RESULT – Rugby World Cup 2023: Irish pick up stunning win and make statement

    South Africa 8-13 Ireland LIVE RESULT – Rugby World Cup 2023: Irish pick up stunning win and make statement

    My new Amazon mirror is a 10/10 – it has a hidden compartment that fits my makeup and jewelry, that’s not the best part

    My new Amazon mirror is a 10/10 – it has a hidden compartment that fits my makeup and jewelry, that’s not the best part

    Rugby World Cup match halted as Namibia star suffers HORROR injury vs New Zealand with ankle left facing wrong way

    Rugby World Cup match halted as Namibia star suffers HORROR injury vs New Zealand with ankle left facing wrong way

    Is Man Utd vs Brighton on TV? Channel, stream, kick-off time and team news for Premier League clash

    Is Man Utd vs Brighton on TV? Channel, stream, kick-off time and team news for Premier League clash

    Wales 0 South Korea 0: Son Heung-min off target while new Spurs team-mate Brennan Johnson looks rusty in bore draw

    Wales 0 South Korea 0: Son Heung-min off target while new Spurs team-mate Brennan Johnson looks rusty in bore draw

    I stayed with my husband despite his secret family and now I regret it

    I stayed with my husband despite his secret family and now I regret it

    Moment Russian ‘electrics factory’ erupts in bright blue fireball after Ukraine launches another late-night drone strike

    Moment Russian ‘electrics factory’ erupts in bright blue fireball after Ukraine launches another late-night drone strike

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Fashion
    • food
    • Health
    • Travel
    I went through the world’s most painful op to get a bit taller… it cost £35k-an-inch & was agony but it was worth it

    I went through the world’s most painful op to get a bit taller… it cost £35k-an-inch & was agony but it was worth it

    Mum sparks fierce debate with her jacket potato ‘birthday cake’, but insists the food mountain was completely devoured

    Mum sparks fierce debate with her jacket potato ‘birthday cake’, but insists the food mountain was completely devoured

    UK landmark crowned the most beautiful UNESCO World Heritage Site in the world

    UK landmark crowned the most beautiful UNESCO World Heritage Site in the world

    Our adorable hairy baby has a legion of fans – they say he can grow a beard better than most men

    Our adorable hairy baby has a legion of fans – they say he can grow a beard better than most men

    Brits’ perfect three-course meal revealed – so do your choices make the menu?

    Brits’ perfect three-course meal revealed – so do your choices make the menu?

    Shrek fans can stay in this iconic swamp for free on Airbnb (and for once, there really is no catch)

    Shrek fans can stay in this iconic swamp for free on Airbnb (and for once, there really is no catch)

    How much have I cost the NHS? How to find out

    How much have I cost the NHS? How to find out

    I’m a mum & have the best tricks to make autumn treats without baking anything – they’re perfect for kids and so easy

    I’m a mum & have the best tricks to make autumn treats without baking anything – they’re perfect for kids and so easy

    This is the UK city with more pubs than any other – and it’s not London

    This is the UK city with more pubs than any other – and it’s not London

    I’m a doctor and these are fountain of youth secrets you actually need to know… & it all starts with gardening

    I’m a doctor and these are fountain of youth secrets you actually need to know… & it all starts with gardening

    Trending Tags

    • Golden Globes
    • Mr. Robot
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Climate Change
    • Flat Earth
  • Health
  • Opinion
  • Tech
  • Science
  • Travel
  • Real Estate
  • Sports
  • More
    • Crypto
    • Press Release
Birmingham Times
No Result
View All Result
Home Business

Mail on Sunday lawyer accuses Prince Harry of ‘straitjacketing’ newspaper’s right to comment in libel hearing

by Chandler
March 19, 2023
Reading Time: 9min read
0
SHARES
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Reddit


A lawyer for the Mail on Sunday accused Prince Harry of “straitjacketing” the newspaper’s “right to comment” during the pair’s latest libel fight.

Harry is suing Mail on Sunday and Mail Online publisher Associated Newspapers and seeking damages and an injunction over a February 2022 article headlined: “EXCLUSIVE: How Prince Harry tried to keep his legal fight with the government over police bodyguards a SECRET… then – just minutes after the story broke – his PR machine tried to put a positive spin on the dispute.”

In July, High Court judge Mr Justice Nicklin ruled parts of the article were defamatory because they contended Harry intended to mislead the public.

He said a reader would think Harry “was responsible for public statements, issued on his behalf, which claimed that he was willing to pay for police protection in the UK, and that his legal challenge was to the Government’s refusal to permit him to do so, whereas the true position, as revealed in documents filed in the legal proceedings, was that he had only made the offer to pay after the proceedings had commenced”.

He also said the article would have been read as alleging Harry “was responsible for trying to mislead and confuse the public as to the true position, which was ironic given that he now held a public role in tackling ‘misinformation’”.

Associated Newspapers is defending the case on the basis of honest opinion under the Defamation Act 2013, arguing Mail on Sunday assistant editor Kate Mansey was approaching the points in her piece as an “honest commentator”.

However lawyers for Prince Harry are attempting to have this defence dismissed, or a summary judgment in his favour given, on the grounds that the newspaper’s case is not strong enough to succeed at trial.

Andrew Caldecott KC, representing Associated Newspapers, told the High Court on Friday that in fact the publisher’s case was a “strong” one and called the stance of Harry’s legal team on multiple aspects “wholly unreasonable”. He claimed “this whole case is built on sand”.

He also contended that it was fact that Harry had not offered to pay for his security in the UK until after launching his application for a judicial review.

“The truth was that no offer to pay had been made to the Home Office before the issue of proceedings,” Caldecott told the High Court. “… it must follow as night does day that the claimant was not challenging a prior decision by the Home Office not to allow him to pay but the Home Office had not received an offer to pay before the proceedings commenced.”

However Justin Rushbrooke KC, representing Harry, said in written argument that the newspaper was “incapable of proving that [Harry] had only made an offer to pay for police protection after the judicial review proceedings had commenced, let alone that the documents filed in those proceedings revealed this to be the case”.

Caldecott also claimed Harry’s legal team had “fundamentally distort[ed]” the meaning given by the judge last year in its arguments, having the “effect of straitjacketing the newspaper’s right to comment”.

Rushbrooke argued in response that they were “not editing” the meaning but they did disagree about what it “has to say”.

Rushbrooke had said “there can be no doubt that the factual allegations relied upon for the defamatory opinion, they essentially break down into two components”: the first “relates to a false claim being made by the claimant or on his behalf about his willingness to pay for police protection in the UK” while the second to a “false claim as to the nature of the legal challenge”.

“If the defence does not even purport to show that [Harry’s] willingness [to pay] is true, then the defence can go nowhere in terms of supporting the objective honesty test,” Rushbrooke said. “We say that that is so as a matter of principle… and as a matter of common sense and fairness.”

Prince Harry Mail on Sunday libel legal teams court sketch
Court artist sketch by Elizabeth Cook of a split screen video link at the Royal Courts of Justice in London on 17 March 2023, showing Judge Nicklin (right) and counsel (left), in the latest hearing in the Duke of Sussex’s libel claim against the publisher of The Mail on Sunday over an article about the duke’s challenge against the Home Office over security arrangements. Picture: PA Wire/Elizabeth Cook

Caldecott, for the Mail on Sunday, claimed in his written argument that Mansey’s email to a representative of Harry before the article was published contained some “pertinent” questions. “There may be no obligation to reply to them but an honest commentator is entitled to look at the absence of reply,” he said.

In court documents, Rushbrooke claimed that other press reporting of Harry’s statement about the judicial review in January 2022 “manifestly did not state, nor did they imply, that [his] legal challenge was to the Government’s decision to refuse his offer to pay for police protection”.

However Caldecott wrote in response: “If that is so, one is entitled to ask why the gist of the headlines and opening text of numerous reputable media entities who covered the public statements is to precisely this effect.”

He told the court it would be “extraordinary if large swathes of the media had a collective misreading of the press statement”. Rushbrooke claimed PA had got the “wrong end of the stick” but Caldecott said the agency got the “right end”.

PA had written in January 2022: “The Duke of Sussex has filed a claim for a judicial review against a Home Office decision not to allow him to personally pay for police protection for himself and his family while in the UK.” A BBC story said: “Prince Harry is seeking a judicial review against a refusal of the Home Office to allow him to personally pay for police protection when in the UK.”

And Omid Scobie, a journalist seen as being sympathetic to the Sussexes according to Rushbrooke, tweeted: “BREAKING: Prince Harry has applied for a judicial review of a Home Office decision not to allow him to personally pay for police protection for himself and his family when they are in the UK, a legal representative for the Sussexes confirms.”

Harry has not claimed these reports were “inaccurate” or “unfair” reports of his public statements, and has made no effort to correct the record to this day, according to Caldecott.

Caldecott said: “The Press Association were entirely right to think this is the punchy summary of what it’s all about. It’s simple – the duke wants himself and his family to be safe and to pay for necessary security but he can’t – unless the Home Office approves his offer.”

The Mail on Sunday itself reported this statement in full after breaking the news of the judicial review. Mansey later, in a request for comment email, provided an opportunity to “consider and correct the inaccuracies in the reporting elsewhere” by highlighting PA’s story and noting that its claim was not in the statement that had been provided to her, but she got no response, the newspaper’s argument said.

That January statement to the press ended with an apparent reference to the Mail on Sunday: “It is due to a leak in a UK tabloid, with surreptitious timing, we feel it necessary to release a statement setting the facts straight,” it said.

However Caldecott told the court Mansey’s email requesting comment “had put a very fair… summary of what the judicial review proceedings were about” and that “people are plainly entitled to ask questions” about Harry’s application.

The judge’s decision will come at a later date.

The post Mail on Sunday lawyer accuses Prince Harry of ‘straitjacketing’ newspaper’s right to comment in libel hearing appeared first on Press Gazette.



Source link

Related Posts

Jeremy Kyle says ‘world has moved on’ since ITV scandal as he joins Nicola Thorp on TalkTV breakfast

Jeremy Kyle says ‘world has moved on’ since ITV scandal as he joins Nicola Thorp on TalkTV breakfast

by Chandler
October 2, 2023
0

Broadcaster Jeremy Kyle has said that “the world has moved on” from his confrontational ITV daytime talk programme, The Jeremy Kyle Show, as he prepared to launch a breakfast show on...

GB News suspends Laurence Fox and Dan Wootton after tirade against female journalist

GB News suspends Laurence Fox and Dan Wootton after tirade against female journalist

by Chandler
September 28, 2023
0

GB News has suspended both Laurence Fox and Dan Wootton over “totally unacceptable” comments made by Fox about a female journalist during Wootton’s show on Tuesday. Ofcom is assessing complaints over the...

News diary 25 September – 1 October: CPS mulls Letby retrial, Jimmy Lai’s 1000th day in prison

News diary 25 September – 1 October: CPS mulls Letby retrial, Jimmy Lai’s 1000th day in prison

by Chandler
September 23, 2023
0

A look ahead at the key events leading the news agenda next week, from the team at Foresight News. Leading the week The case of the UK’s worst child serial killer...

GB News impartiality undermined by Bev Turner support for Russell Brand, MP warns

GB News impartiality undermined by Bev Turner support for Russell Brand, MP warns

by Chandler
September 19, 2023
0

GB News presenter Bev Turner’s vocal support for Russell Brand before she fronted coverage of the allegations against him potentially “undermines any perception of due impartiality in the broadcasting”, the chair...

News diary 18–24 September: Scottish Govt takes UK to court over Gender Recognition Reform Bill block

News diary 18–24 September: Scottish Govt takes UK to court over Gender Recognition Reform Bill block

by Chandler
September 15, 2023
0

A look ahead at the key events leading the news agenda next week, from the team at Foresight News. Leading the week On Tuesday (September 19), the Court of Session begins...

Reach reader revenue trials: Premium apps, paid-for newsletters and ad-free Express

Reach reader revenue trials: Premium apps, paid-for newsletters and ad-free Express

by Chandler
September 11, 2023
0

Reach has expanded its experiments with reader revenue to diversify away from its heavy reliance on advertising, which has seen an industry-wide decline, and build relationships with its most loyal readers....

Next Post
Foreign Sec James Cleverly visits Kazakhstan after country’s refusal to support Russia

Foreign Sec James Cleverly visits Kazakhstan after country’s refusal to support Russia

Popular News

Jeremy Kyle says ‘world has moved on’ since ITV scandal as he joins Nicola Thorp on TalkTV breakfast

Jeremy Kyle says ‘world has moved on’ since ITV scandal as he joins Nicola Thorp on TalkTV breakfast

2 days ago
Britain braced for invasion of creepy cannibal praying mantis

Britain braced for invasion of creepy cannibal praying mantis

2 days ago
Which teams have been eliminated from the Rugby World Cup 2023?

Which teams have been eliminated from the Rugby World Cup 2023?

2 days ago
I went through the world’s most painful op to get a bit taller… it cost £35k-an-inch & was agony but it was worth it

I went through the world’s most painful op to get a bit taller… it cost £35k-an-inch & was agony but it was worth it

2 days ago
Sycamore Gap: Lumberjack returns to farmhouse after being quizzed by police – as cops find giant chainsaw in barn

Sycamore Gap: Lumberjack returns to farmhouse after being quizzed by police – as cops find giant chainsaw in barn

2 days ago
Mum sparks fierce debate with her jacket potato ‘birthday cake’, but insists the food mountain was completely devoured

Mum sparks fierce debate with her jacket potato ‘birthday cake’, but insists the food mountain was completely devoured

2 days ago
Rishi Sunak should be bold on vote-winner policies to show he’s prepared to overturn orthodoxy and truly lead

Rishi Sunak should be bold on vote-winner policies to show he’s prepared to overturn orthodoxy and truly lead

2 days ago
Grant Shapps branded a ‘newly-minted cretin’ by Russia and accused of trying to start World War III

Grant Shapps branded a ‘newly-minted cretin’ by Russia and accused of trying to start World War III

2 days ago
Birmingham Times

All Rights Reserved © Birmingham Times - The Voice of UK

Important Links

  • Publish Your article
  • Editorial Policy
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Advertise

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Politics
  • UK News
  • Business
  • Science
  • National
  • Entertainment
  • Gaming
  • Sports
  • Fashion
  • Lifestyle
  • Travel
  • Health
  • Food

All Rights Reserved © Birmingham Times - The Voice of UK

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In